The Seventh Prompt
Ambiguity
can come into a reading experience in several situations. Sometimes it is the resolution that is left
unclear, sometimes it is events preceding the story that are never made clear,
and even more rarely, entire plot points are left unclear. One
thing that remains constant throughout, however, is that it leaves meaning open
to interpretation.
Leaving
their works ambiguous and open to interpretation is part of what creates
engagement between the reader and the writer.
There is no one way to interpret a piece of art, and even when there is
a clear way to interpret it, there is never a “correct” way. Take, for instance, Quentin Tarantino’s film Pulp Fiction. This film features a briefcase as a central
plot point but never gives any clear indication as to what is contained
inside. The most that is shown is a
glowing golden light emanating from within.
One of the most popular theories is that this briefcase contains the
soul of one of the film’s characters, Marsellus Wallace. There is plenty of evidence to support it,
but does that make it correct? No, part
of the beauty in the film is that what’s inside the briefcase is whatever the
audience thinks it is.
Ambiguity
makes a text more personal because the meaning is just as much the reader’s as
it is the author’s. The author does not
tell anybody exactly what to think, they simply push the reader in a certain direction
and the reader arrives at their own conclusion.
This makes it applicable to a wider variety of situations and time
periods. Readers will often see a
reflection of themselves and their own struggles where something is left
unclear. Maybe it was society’s fault
that this character turned evil, maybe it was his own personal insecurities
that tore him apart, and maybe it was the fault of the failed prison system
that he did not reform. The bottom line
is that ambiguity allows a text to be appreciated from many more angles.
Ambiguity in a piece, whether it be a book, poem, movie or television show, adds a certain edge. As you mentioned, it makes the text more personal to the reader and forms a connection between them and the person who created it. It also encourages creativity by forcing the audience to use their imagination in order to fill holes in the story. This concept, in my opinion, makes consuming literature or films all the more exciting. For example, the conclusion of Gone With the Wind leaves readers wondering what will come of Scarlett and Rhett. Scarlett says, “I'll think of it tomorrow, at Tara. I can stand it then. Tomorrow, I'll think of some way to get him back." With no definite answer as to the status of their relationship, readers must use their imagination to finish the story.
ReplyDeleteI would like to start off by saying your analogy to Pulp Fiction was a great example of the effectiveness of ambiguity in literature. I also agreed with the idea that ambiguity lets the readers form a more personal connection with a character; in my own prompt I stated that my reasoning for believing this is that it forces the reader to choose a interpretation amidst many simultaneously conflicting ones, and I would say that ties in with your thoughts that it opens up an opportunity for the text to be appreciated from many more angles.
ReplyDelete